Leander High School's online student-run newspaper

The Roar

Filed under Columns, Featured

“13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

Graphic scenes can cause harm to some

Baker+used+a+series+of+cassette+tapes+to+record+thirteen+reasons+why+she+decided+to+end+her+life.+Netflix+translated+this+to+12+episodes+that+covered+seven+tapes.
Baker used a series of cassette tapes to record thirteen reasons why she decided to end her life. Netflix translated this to 12 episodes that covered seven tapes.

Baker used a series of cassette tapes to record thirteen reasons why she decided to end her life. Netflix translated this to 12 episodes that covered seven tapes.

Via Netflix.com

Via Netflix.com

Baker used a series of cassette tapes to record thirteen reasons why she decided to end her life. Netflix translated this to 12 episodes that covered seven tapes.

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Netflix’s original series “13 Reasons Why”, based on Jay Asher’s eponymous book, has come under fire from parents for their portrayal of mature subjects. The series focuses on the suicide of female high school student Hannah Baker and the multiple cassette tapes detailing why she decided to take her life. Some scenes, especially those depicting suicide and rape, are too graphic for some to watch without negative effects.

The show is rated TV-MA, which means the content may be unsuitable for those under the age of 17. Some parents are unaware their children, under the age of 17, have watched the show, according to Lauren Adbill, author of op-ed piece “There’s no reason to buy ‘13 Reasons Why’ imagery”.

Many are worried of the message the show is sending to susceptible youth. Author and father Jack VanNoord considered the show “highly problematic” due to the graphic depiction of several scenes, including rape, self-harm, and suicide. Mary Ann O’Rourke, whose son died by suicide, wrote in a letter that the series communicates a “horrible message” for teenagers and young adults in their portrayal of suicide.

The National Association of School Psychologists published an essay on “13 Reasons Why” with their recommendations. In the piece, the organization recommended that vulnerable youth shouldn’t watch the series and gave guidance to educators, families, and students for dealing with the series and suicide. The essay highlighted a scene where Baker seeks help from a school counselor to no avail and warned that it didn’t “inspire a sense of trust or ability to help”.

Suicide is a major issue among adolescents. It is the second-leading cause of death on college campuses. This is a serious issue that needs to be addressed seriously.”

— Lauren Adbill

In Adbill’s op-ed, she critiqued the show for not following the American Association of Suicidology’s recommendations for how media should depict suicide. The guidelines include practicing non-sensitization, adding warning signs and guidance, and more.

Executive producer Selena Gomez defended the show, calling it “true to the book.” However, reading about graphic events versus watching them on television are very different. In the show, Baker, on camera, slit her wrists. The scene depicted graphic cuts and blood. In the novel, Baker’s suicide, where she used unspecified pills, wasn’t shown.

The scenes depicted can negatively affect some of those who watch it. The series has a TV-MA rating for a reason, but some may choose to watch it regardless. Netflix has advertised the show broadly across their platform as a Netflix Original series with banner ads and enlarged titles. The rating is obscured next to insignificant data, like the year and number of seasons. Because of this, students may not be aware of the graphicity of the show and the negative effects it can have on their mental health.

If you are in crisis or you know of someone who is, you may want to call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-8255 or visit suicidepreventionlifeline.org.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Comment

Comments are closed.

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Summer days

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Reaching out

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Long road ahead

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Top five things to do in May

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Beat

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Not an anomaly

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    A hateful heritage

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Six months

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    Top five shows on Netflix in April

  • “13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic

    Columns

    She’s a dream

Leander High School's online student-run newspaper
“13 Reasons Why” it’s problematic